Thoughts are a Planet. The Body is the Sun. Occupy your Being. Join the revolution.

George Monbiot makes an interesting statement in this morning’s Guardian. He points out that there is a myth: that the people at the top of corporations are financial geniuses who got their wealth by merit of their brilliant minds and hard work. This myth is false, he says. It is a self-attribution fallacy, a myth of election. Not only do these people not have superhuman talents but:

they have preyed on the earth’s natural wealth and their workers’ labour and creativity, impoverishing both people and planet. Now they have almost bankrupted us. The wealth creators of neoliberal mythology are some of the most effective wealth destroyers the world has ever seen.

I agree with Monbiot’s politics and I too believe that the unbridled greed of unregulated capitalism has put psychopathy in the driving seat of our culture with disasterous results.

But as I was running around Shoreditch park trying to shake of a turn-of-the-season cold, I was also reflecting on another myth-busting shift that is happening. It’s more subtle and slow-moving than the dynamic Occupy movements that are springing up all over the globe, but it is I believe complementary and phenomenally powerful.

It’s debunking the myth that our thinking self is the central axis of our being in the world.

More and more of the neuroscientific evidence and research in contemporary therapy point to a fallacy which is right at the heart of our psychic version of the Eurozone crisis.

Our thoughts believe they are geniuses. They too suffer from a self-attribution fantasy. Although most thinkers acknoweledge the existence of a body below the neck and are buffeted about by their emotions, the strident voice of our thoughts are like Charlie Chaplin’s great dictator shouting and shouting and shouting.

Yet our ‘being’ goes on quite happily when our thoughts blank out during sleep. While we are thinking furiously about a house we want to buy or an argument we need to win, our body goes on breathing and digesting and blooding quite unconcerned with the strutting voice of the thinking mind.

What made me think about this was that half way round Shoreditch park I found myself stuck in an angry little groove, thinking about a troublesome friend of mine and my anger at him. Round and round: a jumping needle on a record. So then I practised a trick I teach people on meditation courses: flushing. Simply bring all your attention to your senses: to what you can see, smell, feel, hear. Let the images and details and colours and tastes flush through your system and ‘dislodge’ the stuck needle.

A little voice in my head said: ah, but you’re just repressing the thought. And then it struck me: but why is thought more real than the sound of people playing five-aside-football or the colour of those leaves under the sodium street lights? It’s a brainwash to think that thoughts are at the centre of things.

They really aren’t.

Neuroscience shows that most decisions are made and acted upon seconds before the thought “I’m deciding this” shows up. Our emotions, body and energy are all enacting our lives long before we think about acting.

Just as the Arab Spring showed that one illusory system can fall overnight and something new can arise, sustained mindfulness practice can undermine the phoney dictatorship of the thinking mind to such a point that it collapses and, in the aftermath, we realise we were being duped and we’re better off without it.

I’m talking about a Copernican revolution.

We have been gulled to believe that our Being revolves around our conscious thoughts. But this is like Ptolemy’s model of the sun revolving round the Earth. It seemed commonsensical but it causes major, irreconcilable problems because it is not true. If however, we start to entertain the notion that our being radiates out from around our body and that our thoughts are (important but peripheral) satellites then things make a lot more sense. Throw in the energy that radiates out from the Body-Sun and you have a solar system of Being that suddenly functions properly.

Thoughts can be terrible wealth-destroyers when we believe they are the centre of our Being. Allow them their place in the orbit around the energetic Sun of the body and the enormous solar wealth of Being can be fairly distributed again.


  1. Kim

    November 10, 2011 at 1:55 am

    Thank you, Alistair, for posting this concept — so timely! Over the last few weeks, I have been learning about the concept of humans as spirits/souls having an earthly body experience — rather than the other way around. Thoughts are part of that bodily experience, and are often at odds with our true nature.

    Now, I read your post, which essentially supports the same concept: our true being –> our body –> our thoughts, in that order. I loveloveLOVE the Copernican analogy: so true! Count me in as a revolutionary. 🙂

  2. Jo@simplybeingmum

    November 10, 2011 at 11:52 am

    Coincidentally I found this post from a conversation on Facebook about someone watching ‘escape to the country’ when they did still watch TV. Which they now don’t. Since deciding to lead a simpler life, I’ve become interested in learning more about Buddhism – and this looks a great place to start…

  3. May

    November 11, 2011 at 2:25 pm

    You are so right! Interesting and attractive thoughts (thoughts, unfortunately), Alistair. Now I understand my habit of “wait and see what I’ll DO” when a difficult decision has to be made. I literally watch my actions sometimes. It always works. I do have one problem, though, and that is when (new)love or a sex drive comes into the picture: I do not really trust my actions there, the old mind HAS to be involved – in our society at least.
    All best,

  4. scylla

    November 13, 2011 at 3:06 pm

    Are you sure you “agree with Monbiot’s politics”? George believes in a nuclear solution, and furthermore admits to being a failed anarchist (politically the highest calling). Living without fixation on end result is certainly a challenge, as George discovered, but pushing nuclear as panacea is iniquitous . Nuclear dumping by western nations off Somalia, depleted uranium used in bombing of Fallujah where incidence of radiation is higher than Hiroshima. No George, your momentary revolutionary glow only highlights your vision as flawed.

  5. Adam

    November 23, 2011 at 4:06 am

    Interesting how some people can be inspirational just by being conversational. Nice one Alistair.

    The flushing technique is what I so desperately needed. It’s not an instafix, but it’s definitely helping.

Leave a Reply